Nourish The Soul, Hair & Body: How The Donadios Do All Three

By Joshua Anderson for the Peekskill Business Improvement District

Located below the Lofts on Main at 922 Main Street in Peekskill, NY, Nourish Hair & Body stands out for its focus on specialization over variety.

Co-owner and lead stylist John Donadio specializes in precision haircutting and color application. His wife and co-owner, Lydia Donadio, specializes in therapeutic massage for clients dealing with serious physical ailments.

Both John and Lydia deliberately do fewer things at a very high level. John takes a deeply analytical approach to each cut, examining a client’s jawline, nose line, cheekbone placement and facial symmetry before matching a style to the individual.

His work includes women’s short hairstyles, particularly pixies, A-line bobs, and chin-length cuts. John relies heavily on studying each client’s face. When COVID-19 forced clients to wear masks, that process became considerably more difficult.

“The hardest thing to do I’ve ever done in this business by a mile was to cut blind,” John said.

That analytical approach does not mean imposing the same vision on every client.

Mary Gifford-Smith, who has been going to John for about 20 years, said he has consistently balanced changing trends with her own personal style.

“He’s always been really respectful of who I am and what my personal style is,” Gifford-Smith said.

“I don’t have to think about being fashionable because he does that for me,” she added.

Gifford-Smith is one of John’s longtime clients. Now living in Long Island City, she travels roughly an hour and a half to Nourish about every five weeks for her color, cut and blowout.

She has followed John through several locations, and her adult children now go to Nourish as well. That confidence in his work also means John is willing to tell clients “no” when he believes a requested style will not work with their face shape.

“This isn’t baseball. I don’t have the ability to strike out. Like, you don’t come in and pay this money and you go, ‘Man, that’s terrible,'” John said.

He added, “I’m not an upsell guy. I just wanna do good work. Just wanna put out good work, man.”

That focus on doing things their own way is also what led John and Lydia to open Nourish together. Lydia started her career working with a chiropractor in southern Westchester before maintaining her own private massage space in White Plains.

Working with the chiropractor exposed Lydia to clients dealing with a wide range of medical conditions, from runners with Achilles problems to people with multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease and cancer.

“I realized that the kind of massage that I wanted to do was also medical based. I had no interest in being in a spa setting,” Lydia said.

The genesis of Nourish? “I just wanted to hang out with my wife. That’s it. I was like, ‘Well, we’re just gonna get to spend all the time together,'” John continued. “And we do.”

The two decided to start their business together in February 2013 at 2229 Crompond Road in Cortlandt Manor. The couple remained there before moving to 922 Main Street, their current location since 2019.

On a day out for lunch in downtown Peekskill, they happened to notice the building that would become Nourish’s new home and decided to jump on the opportunity. Peekskill was where they wanted to be from the beginning.

“We love Peekskill… it was important for us to be here. And we were so happy when we could move here,” Lydia said.

The salon’s emphasis on specialized work and treatments extends to Lydia’s side of the business. After 16 years as a licensed massage therapist, Lydia remains focused on therapeutic, problem-solving work rather than the traditional spa experience.

“My clients know that I love problems, and they come in with problems and we figure out how to make them better,” Lydia said.

“If you have a problem, this is the massage therapist you wanna go to,” she added.

One longtime client stands out to Lydia as an example of the progress she has seen through her work.

“She came in in a walker. Her husband had to literally help her get undressed in the room. She could barely lay down, and now she just bops in here. So, watching things like that are super gratifying,” Lydia said.

That same emphasis on long-term relationships extends to Nourish’s staff, where John has built an apprenticeship-style approach centered on training stylists himself and developing them over time before they earn a chair of their own.

The stylists at Nourish Hair & Body include John, the lead stylist; Nikole Kristoferson, who has been there for six years; Sharon Crespo, who has been there for five years; and Karen McInerney, who has been there for four years and is currently a junior stylist.

Senior stylist Nikole Kristoferson arrived at Nourish in February 2020 as an 18-year-old Putnam Valley High School senior studying cosmetology through Putnam/Northern Westchester BOCES.

Her teacher had referred her to John, and after a roughly two-hour interview, Kristoferson started at Nourish a week later. She had plans to be a teacher and was set to go to college, yet this opportunity to work under John changed that path. During their downtime, John trained her on mannequins, breaking haircuts down step by step.

“I was very fortunate to have somebody who really showed me how to do this, rather than just throwing me into the deep end,” Kristoferson said.

She said cosmetology school taught the fundamentals needed for licensing, including safety and infection control — while John taught her how to solve problems behind the chair. Today, Kristoferson specializes in many of the precision cuts John emphasizes, including bobs and pixies, along with clipper cuts and complete transformations.

John’s training goes beyond just Nourish. He also teaches haircutting demonstrations at the local BOCES technical center, which has served as a pipeline for several of the salon’s stylists.

“I’m not the type of boss that would sit home and let them do it. I’m here every day. I’m the guy. I’m behind the chair grinding, ’cause you lead by example,” John said.

His standards can be demanding, she said, but his criticism is direct rather than personal. If something is wrong, he pulls her aside and explains it.

“When John tells you you’re great, you know it’s coming from a really important spot — and he’s not saying it just to say it,” Kristoferson said. “There’s a lot of pride behind it.”

This training is also reflected in Nourish’s tiered pricing, with rates based on each stylist’s experience. Demand remains high: John sees roughly eight to 12 clients a day and can be booked more than a month ahead.

That demand has extended beyond John. Kristoferson said that even during August, typically a slower period for the salon, she can be booked two to three weeks ahead and has no intention of leaving Nourish anytime soon.

“I’m 25 years old, live on my own. Not a lot of 25-year-olds can do that right now,” she said.

Despite the demand, the Donadios have prioritized sustainability over constant growth. They operate four regular days a week, giving themselves time for family and allowing both John and Lydia to sustain long work days.

That schedule has also given Lydia greater flexibility while raising their two daughters, as John concentrates his salon hours into longer workdays. Lydia believes the additional day away from the salon has helped John physically sustain his 35-year career.

“That extra day off physically and mentally I think is part of the reason he’s lasted so long in this career,” Lydia said.

From the client side, Gifford-Smith said that appointments do not feel rushed once clients are inside.

“It’s never been about turnover and lots of clients as much as possible,” Gifford-Smith said.

Instead, she described an environment where clients are greeted personally, appointments generally begin on time and conversation is as much a part of the experience as the service itself.

The salon relies mostly on word of mouth to get their name around; its reputation is what precedes it.

“You don’t get that for free. You earn that, right? You gotta be on point all the time. So it keeps you humble,” John said.

Nourish Hair & Body is open Wednesday from 10 a.m.-7 p.m., Thursday and Friday from 10 a.m.-8 p.m., and Saturday from 9 a.m.-5 p.m. The salon is closed Sunday through Tuesday and operates by appointment only.

For more information about hair services, massage therapy, pricing or appointments, call 914-930-7777, visit nourishhairandbody.com, or stop by 922 Main St., Suite C, Peekskill, NY 10566.

(C) 2026 Peekskill Business Improvement District. Photos by Joshua Anderson. Some photos provided by K&P. Edited by Bill Powers.  If you are a downtown destination business and would like to be considered for an upcoming profile article, please email us at peekskillbid1@gmail.com.